My Really Truly Christmas Songs
Viewing comments for Chapter 1 "Introduction"A Collection of my own Compositions for Christmas
73 total reviews
Comment from michaelcahill
This is well-written. I think it is a good idea to have an introduction page to your collection. It does give a guide to the reader and a focus as to what some of the thoughts you had going on when you wrote these. That always adds to the enjoyment of the work. Readers always enjoy having a bit of the inside scoop! mikey
reply by the author on 07-Apr-2014
  |
This is well-written. I think it is a good idea to have an introduction page to your collection. It does give a guide to the reader and a focus as to what some of the thoughts you had going on when you wrote these. That always adds to the enjoyment of the work. Readers always enjoy having a bit of the inside scoop! mikey
Comment Written 07-Apr-2014
reply by the author on 07-Apr-2014
-
Thanks mate for dropping by. yeah especially the later carol not sure if I told you I dived (you guys say "DOVE!!" Grmph!) out of bed at 5am one morning as I just had to get the words down and I already had the tune in mind.
Comment from Tomes Johnston
This is a good explanation of your idea. It is better late than never. I have just got back from my holiday in Thailand and Cambodia with my fiance. It was great but it is good to ba back as well.
reply by the author on 06-Apr-2014
|
This is a good explanation of your idea. It is better late than never. I have just got back from my holiday in Thailand and Cambodia with my fiance. It was great but it is good to ba back as well.
Comment Written 06-Apr-2014
reply by the author on 06-Apr-2014
-
AMEN mate good to see you.Thanks for the review. Hope you had a good time. Hope you guys are gonna tie the knot soon! Did you see my message about John Wayne's movie "Sea Chase" we just watched, reminding me of 'The Beast'?
-
I saw the message and I will watch this movie again. I am a great John Wayne fan. Thank you.
-
Might give you some more ideas for Beast too did you finish that yet?
-
It is finished, but I just need to post the rest on here.
Comment from Shirley E Kennedy
We find inspiration and a reason to follow chosen paths from all kinds of things.
It's interesting to note that your reason was to fill a gap in Christian
Christmas Carols which presented the true meaning of Christmas.
To write both words and music is quite a challenge.
Good luck.
reply by the author on 06-Apr-2014
|
We find inspiration and a reason to follow chosen paths from all kinds of things.
It's interesting to note that your reason was to fill a gap in Christian
Christmas Carols which presented the true meaning of Christmas.
To write both words and music is quite a challenge.
Good luck.
Comment Written 06-Apr-2014
reply by the author on 06-Apr-2014
-
hi friend the carols are already on in The "Really Truly Christmas Carols" book. I wrote most in the mid seventies as I said and the last one in 2003. Hope you enjoy them. Thanks for the great reciew
Comment from Gladness
Nice introduction. I am looking forward to reading the lyrics of the carols you wrote. There can't be enough songs to glorify our great God.
Anita
reply by the author on 05-Apr-2014
|
Nice introduction. I am looking forward to reading the lyrics of the carols you wrote. There can't be enough songs to glorify our great God.
Anita
Comment Written 05-Apr-2014
reply by the author on 05-Apr-2014
-
Hi Friend I thought you would have seen the Carols before as they have been on here for ages in the "Really Truly Christmas Carols" Book. Thanks for the review I felt the Intro was long overdue for the collection in the book. God Bless.
Comment from barbara.wilkey
Well, I for one, can't wait. It seems you have done a great service for other's here and I am off to read the first induction.
reply by the author on 05-Apr-2014
|
Well, I for one, can't wait. It seems you have done a great service for other's here and I am off to read the first induction.
Comment Written 05-Apr-2014
reply by the author on 05-Apr-2014
-
Hi they have been on the website for ages I just felt like an Introduction was most needed.
Comment from Norbanus
This could be a startling prologue for some, Sankey. Christmas Carols have in the past, have been to show the murder of Jesus as less ghastly than it was, in order to allow people to think of the salvation rather than the horror. I'm looking forward to seeing your carols.
reply by the author on 05-Apr-2014
|
This could be a startling prologue for some, Sankey. Christmas Carols have in the past, have been to show the murder of Jesus as less ghastly than it was, in order to allow people to think of the salvation rather than the horror. I'm looking forward to seeing your carols.
Comment Written 05-Apr-2014
reply by the author on 05-Apr-2014
-
Hi friend the Carols have been in the "Really Truly Christmas Carols" book on FS for ages just felt an Intro was more than overdue.
Comment from c_lucas
I trust your songs will not remove Jesus from his place in the Christmases of tomorrow. This is very well written and I look forward to your endeavor.
reply by the author on 04-Apr-2014
|
I trust your songs will not remove Jesus from his place in the Christmases of tomorrow. This is very well written and I look forward to your endeavor.
Comment Written 04-Apr-2014
reply by the author on 04-Apr-2014
-
Thanks mate this intro is way past all the Carols I wrote yesrs ago. I just felt I needed to do an introduction so here ya go. Have put up the most recent Carol for review again today not sure if you saw them yet.
-
I should be on your fan list. You're welcome, Sankey. Charlie
Comment from royowen
Thank you Geoff, for posting this comprehensive explanation for writing and promoting the sort of music that glorifies The Lord at a time that most are thinking of other things, and believing that Christmas is for other things than celebrating Jesus' birth! Bless you, Roy.
reply by the author on 04-Apr-2014
|
Thank you Geoff, for posting this comprehensive explanation for writing and promoting the sort of music that glorifies The Lord at a time that most are thinking of other things, and believing that Christmas is for other things than celebrating Jesus' birth! Bless you, Roy.
Comment Written 04-Apr-2014
reply by the author on 04-Apr-2014
-
Thanks Bro apologies that it is not nearer the time but as we don't know when Christ was born...some suggest more like a September than December I thought a good idea for an introduction finally.
-
It's not your fault Geoff, I think it was the Emperor Constantine who replaced a Pagan festival, as was Easter which was celebrating a fertility Goddess, and Christmas the sun and moon. It is ironic, the Hebrew feasts which were eternally instituted by God, we avoid them! Blessings, Roy. Just having a bleet!
-
Bro Roy I know all about old incontinent Constantine sorry couldn't help it. I guess when you make something up or institute something you have to add your own angle, Hence Christmass. One only has to look around St peter's Square in Rome to see all the "hangovers" from Paganism huh! And don't get me started on Mariolatry and so on.Good thing about Christmas and Easter apart from all the gaff is these are probably the only times many would even be in a church and hopefully if they are lucky hear the Gospel.
-
I used to have a problem about Christmas and Easter and then I grew up and decided that anyday is the time to glorify The Lord, and if it brings awareness of God, by those that don't know Him, then I am for it! Bless you and your dear wife today and always. Roy.
-
AMEn Bro hung around 2 women for years on the Forums who were really agro about Christmas and Easter. Both ex Cathaholics hehe. I used to know when to steer clear of them as the rest of the year they were terrific people. Actually sorry one was ex Lutheran.
-
Poor Geoff, I'm sorry to say, sometimes we get hung up on things that simply aren't important! Thanks for sharing! Roy.
Comment from Dean Kuch
I'm certainly receptive to the demonetization of the commercialism which Christmas seems to be all about these days. You're lucky if you don't offend someone anymore should you wish them a very merry Christmas, and I feel that's such a shame.
Our forefathers founded this country on Christian principles and morals. Those who take offense to that can go back to where they came from, as far as I'm concerned...
reply by the author on 04-Apr-2014
|
I'm certainly receptive to the demonetization of the commercialism which Christmas seems to be all about these days. You're lucky if you don't offend someone anymore should you wish them a very merry Christmas, and I feel that's such a shame.
Our forefathers founded this country on Christian principles and morals. Those who take offense to that can go back to where they came from, as far as I'm concerned...
Comment Written 04-Apr-2014
reply by the author on 04-Apr-2014
-
And all the Lord's people said 'AMEN! thanks Dean! Appreciate your great review. I sense we are on the same page mate.
-
I would definitely say so, my friend!
Comment from judiverse
This is a fine introductory note about your collection of poems. You explain when they were written and also give an excellent explanation for why you thought they were necessary. As you state, a lot of the Christmas carols do not really convey the true meaning of Christmas. Sounds like a great project. judi
reply by the author on 04-Apr-2014
|
This is a fine introductory note about your collection of poems. You explain when they were written and also give an excellent explanation for why you thought they were necessary. As you state, a lot of the Christmas carols do not really convey the true meaning of Christmas. Sounds like a great project. judi
Comment Written 04-Apr-2014
reply by the author on 04-Apr-2014
-
Thanks friend for coming over. I do appreciate your time as I know you are a busy lady. God Bless.
-
You're so welcome. Best of luck with your collection. judi
-
Hi mate in case you had not realised the Carold have been up in the Really Truly Christmas Carols book on here for ages. The introduction is an afterthought ok!