Calvin
A quiet mountain man.39 total reviews
Comment from John Ciarmello
I loved this poem, Willie. It read well and smoothly. The content was super interesting. I have to ask, is this a fictional character? or perhaps someone you knew? Curious. Best, JohnC
reply by the author on 27-Sep-2022
  |
I loved this poem, Willie. It read well and smoothly. The content was super interesting. I have to ask, is this a fictional character? or perhaps someone you knew? Curious. Best, JohnC
Comment Written 17-Sep-2022
reply by the author on 27-Sep-2022
-
Purely fictional. These poems pop in my head, mostly from dreams. I lived on a farm and ranch most of my life. I met and became friends with many old story tellers. Thanks, John for the review and stars.
Comment from Write Right Writer
Willie...
Excellent work. I very much enjoyed your tribute to this unknown (or known?) mountain man. Your character development was particularly strong. Not only did I know about him, I felt like I knew him.
Concise theme; laser-like focus; lively pace and excellent flow leading to a clear and satisfying destination; steady rhythm, flawless rhyme and rhyming pattern (aabb). The few liberties you took with the meter were well played; especially the pattern interrupt in your final couplet.
Keep up the great work and thanks for sharing this ode to Calvin Short with us.
Curt (WRW)
|
Willie...
Excellent work. I very much enjoyed your tribute to this unknown (or known?) mountain man. Your character development was particularly strong. Not only did I know about him, I felt like I knew him.
Concise theme; laser-like focus; lively pace and excellent flow leading to a clear and satisfying destination; steady rhythm, flawless rhyme and rhyming pattern (aabb). The few liberties you took with the meter were well played; especially the pattern interrupt in your final couplet.
Keep up the great work and thanks for sharing this ode to Calvin Short with us.
Curt (WRW)
Comment Written 17-Sep-2022
Comment from Pam (respa)
-Nice artwork and presentation, Willie.
-You wrote a good poem with effective imagery and rhyme.
-You give us a good word picture of the mountain man.
-He sounds like an upstanding, honest man.
-I like the lines
"A happy ending you won't find any,
Better men, there ain't been many."
-A good concluding couplet.
-Thanks for sharing his story.
|
-Nice artwork and presentation, Willie.
-You wrote a good poem with effective imagery and rhyme.
-You give us a good word picture of the mountain man.
-He sounds like an upstanding, honest man.
-I like the lines
"A happy ending you won't find any,
Better men, there ain't been many."
-A good concluding couplet.
-Thanks for sharing his story.
Comment Written 17-Sep-2022
Comment from Father Flaps
Hi Willie,
I enjoyed the story of Calvin Short, the mountain man. It reminded me of that terrific 1972 movie, "Jeremiah Johnson", starring Robert Redford, and Will Geer as "Bear Claw" Chris Lapp.
I especially liked the final two lines, which were almost an epitaph...
"Few people even knew his name,
He entered the world quietly and left the same"
Thanks for sharing! Living in the mountains was no easy life. Mountain men were tough. I'd love to live in a log cabin. Dreamed about it for many years, but never followed through. My everlasting great regret!
Cheers,
Kimbob
|
Hi Willie,
I enjoyed the story of Calvin Short, the mountain man. It reminded me of that terrific 1972 movie, "Jeremiah Johnson", starring Robert Redford, and Will Geer as "Bear Claw" Chris Lapp.
I especially liked the final two lines, which were almost an epitaph...
"Few people even knew his name,
He entered the world quietly and left the same"
Thanks for sharing! Living in the mountains was no easy life. Mountain men were tough. I'd love to live in a log cabin. Dreamed about it for many years, but never followed through. My everlasting great regret!
Cheers,
Kimbob
Comment Written 17-Sep-2022
Comment from amahra
So Calvin was a real guy. Cool. It's great that you wrote an Ode to him. I love the artwork and the beautiful font you used. What's the name of the font? The poem was lovely and told a great story.
|
So Calvin was a real guy. Cool. It's great that you wrote an Ode to him. I love the artwork and the beautiful font you used. What's the name of the font? The poem was lovely and told a great story.
Comment Written 17-Sep-2022
Comment from Jannypan (Jan)
Your poem was well thought out, Willie. I enjoyed reading
it. I liked the picture you paired with your well-chosen,
meaningful words. The rhymes worked well, too. Your words
painted a picture of this mountain man who worked the land
and was never a 'hero.' However as you wrote, he and others
like him were important in the settling and prospering of the
USA. Great color scheme and font use, too.
Thanks for sharing, Jan
|
Your poem was well thought out, Willie. I enjoyed reading
it. I liked the picture you paired with your well-chosen,
meaningful words. The rhymes worked well, too. Your words
painted a picture of this mountain man who worked the land
and was never a 'hero.' However as you wrote, he and others
like him were important in the settling and prospering of the
USA. Great color scheme and font use, too.
Thanks for sharing, Jan
Comment Written 17-Sep-2022
Comment from sunnilicious
This was a nice Ode to Calvin Short. I haven't heard him before now, however, you're well informed. And it's like I know him now. Well thought out. Clearly written. Excellent work. Great overall presentation.
Happy Apple Dumpling Day
|
This was a nice Ode to Calvin Short. I haven't heard him before now, however, you're well informed. And it's like I know him now. Well thought out. Clearly written. Excellent work. Great overall presentation.
Happy Apple Dumpling Day
Comment Written 17-Sep-2022
Comment from Sandra Nelms-Ludwig
This is a well-told, rhyming poem about a mountain man. The story of his life is clearly stated in chronological order. The text can be easily read. The visual fits perfectly.
I would drop the poem down one notch from the bottom of the visual. The text needs to be bold or a thicker text to fit the ruggedness of the man you described. The text you have selected is a delicate font. Keep sharing! This is a good poem.
|
This is a well-told, rhyming poem about a mountain man. The story of his life is clearly stated in chronological order. The text can be easily read. The visual fits perfectly.
I would drop the poem down one notch from the bottom of the visual. The text needs to be bold or a thicker text to fit the ruggedness of the man you described. The text you have selected is a delicate font. Keep sharing! This is a good poem.
Comment Written 17-Sep-2022
Comment from SLMorrical
I would have liked to give you 6 stars, but have used my weekly allocation. I really liked this and could picture the wild west and the person you wrote about. This flows so well that it was an easy read to follow. Well done.
|
I would have liked to give you 6 stars, but have used my weekly allocation. I really liked this and could picture the wild west and the person you wrote about. This flows so well that it was an easy read to follow. Well done.
Comment Written 17-Sep-2022
Comment from RodG
I love reading about mountain men, but I never heard of Calvin Short. Besides trapping beaver and living with others like him, what made his life noteworthy?
This rating does not count towards story rating or author rank.
The highest and the lowest rating are not included in calculations.
reply by the author on 27-Sep-2022
 |
I love reading about mountain men, but I never heard of Calvin Short. Besides trapping beaver and living with others like him, what made his life noteworthy?
This rating does not count towards story rating or author rank.
The highest and the lowest rating are not included in calculations.
Comment Written 17-Sep-2022
reply by the author on 27-Sep-2022
-
He is fiction. He was like so many others who helped shape our country. Men and women who lived in that time were hard workers, asked for nothing and are very worthy of praise. Thanks, Rod, for the review. Willie